Pumpkin Butter Recipe: Why You Freeze It, Not Can It
Pumpkin butter is pumpkin cooked down with sugar and spice into a thick spread, and it belongs in the fridge or freezer, never canned. The USDA and the National Center for Home Food Preservation do not recommend canning it. Eat it within 3 to 4 days or freeze it for months.
Originally published: November 19, 2026
Food safety note. There is no tested home canning process for pumpkin butter, mashed pumpkin or pumpkin puree, in a water bath or a pressure canner. Adding lemon juice, vinegar or extra sugar does not make it safe to can. Refrigerate it or freeze it.
Pumpkin Butter at a Glance
- Canning: not recommended by the USDA or NCHFP. Not in a water bath, not in a pressure canner.
- Refrigerator: 3 to 4 days for fresh pumpkin butter (Illinois Extension).
- Freezer: up to 8 months to 1 year, depending on the recipe (UC Master Food Preservers).
- Headspace for freezing: 1/2 inch.
- Thaw: in the refrigerator, not on the counter.
What Is Pumpkin Butter?
It is the pumpkin version of apple butter: cooked pumpkin blended smooth, then simmered with sugar, juice and warm spices until it holds its shape on a spoon. It goes on toast and muffins, swirls into pancakes, and bakes into cookies and cheesecake. If you have a pile of pie pumpkins on the porch, it is one of the best ways to use them.
The difference from apple butter is the storage. Apple butter has tested canning directions. Pumpkin butter does not, and that is not an oversight.
Can You Can Pumpkin Butter?
No. The National Center for Home Food Preservation (NCHFP) says it plainly in its post “Beware: Pumpkin Butter”: “home canning is NOT recommended for pumpkin butter or any mashed or pureed pumpkin or winter squash.” In the 1994 revision of the USDA’s Complete Guide to Home Canning, the only directions for canning pumpkin and winter squash are for cubed pulp, and the cubed directions carry the line “Caution: Do not mash or puree.”
Elizabeth Andress, then project director for NCHFP, put it this way in a University of Georgia report: “Home canning isn’t recommended for pumpkin butter, mashed or pureed pumpkin.” Pumpkin butters “can’t be safely canned for room temperature storage. Refrigerate or freeze these items to make sure they’re safe.”
You will still find old recipes and social media posts that can it. Illinois Extension’s pumpkin preservation page warns about exactly those: recipes for canning pureed pumpkin or pumpkin butter “are not evidence-based and therefore not safe for use,” and some cite outdated methods. Grandma’s recipe card is not a lab test.
Why Is Pumpkin Butter Unsafe to Can?
Because nobody can predict what is in the jar. NCHFP lays out three problems:
- It is low-acid. Pumpkin and winter squash have a pH above 4.6. If Clostridium botulinum spores survive processing and the product is moist enough, they can produce the toxin that causes botulism, an illness that can kill.
- The acidity swings. University of Missouri research published in 1995 found batches made from the same formula had widely varying pH, and pumpkin butters made by home canners tested as high as pH 5.4.
- The thickness swings. University of Minnesota studies in the 1970s found so much variation in pumpkin puree thickness that a single processing recommendation to cover it all could not be calculated. The UC Master Food Preservers add that tests have not found a heat process that guarantees an even temperature through it.
Now, what about adding acid? NCHFP addressed that too: even with a lot of sugar, it “may not be enough to inhibit pathogens,” and vinegar or lemon juice cannot be counted on because the starting pH varies so much. With no tested time, there is no way to know a given jar was processed long enough. Our guide to preventing botulism when canning covers why low-acid foods get this much caution.
If you want pumpkin on the pantry shelf, NCHFP has one tested process: 1-inch cubes in a pressure canner. Mash them after you open the jar. Our pumpkin puree guide walks through it.

How Do You Make Pumpkin Butter?
This is the Pumpkin-Ginger Butter recipe the UC Cooperative Extension Master Food Preservers of El Dorado County publish on their “Pumpkin Butter 3 Ways” sheet, adapted from The All New Ball Book of Canning and Preserving. It starts from a whole pie pumpkin, which suits a homestead kitchen. It makes about 6 half-pints.
- 1 pie pumpkin (3 pounds), peeled, seeded and cubed (about 8 cups)
- 1 cup apple juice
- 2 tablespoons minced fresh ginger
- 2 cups firmly packed light brown sugar
- 2 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
- 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1/8 teaspoon ground cloves
- Bring the pumpkin, apple juice and ginger to a boil in a 4-quart non-reactive pot. Cover, reduce the heat, and simmer 30 minutes or until the pumpkin is very soft.
- Blend the mixture in two batches until smooth, pouring each batch into a bowl.
- Return it to the pot. Stir in the brown sugar, lemon juice and spices.
- Cook partially covered over medium-low heat for 20 minutes, or until it thickens and holds its shape on a spoon. Stir often; thick pumpkin spits like a mud pot when it bubbles, so wear long sleeves.
- Spoon it into freezer-safe jars, leaving 1/2-inch headspace. Put the lids on with the bands loose and let the jars cool completely on a wire rack.
- Freeze. Once the butter is frozen, tighten the bands to fingertip tight.
The lemon juice is there for flavor. It does not make this recipe safe to can.
Pie pumpkins are the right choice here. Illinois Extension says to wash the rind with cool running water before cutting and to use a clean, sharp knife, since sharp knives reduce the risk of injury. If your pumpkins came off the porch, our post on post-Halloween pumpkin procedures covers which ones are still fit for the kitchen.
How Long Does Pumpkin Butter Last in the Refrigerator?
Three to four days. Illinois Extension says homemade pumpkin puree or butter can be made fresh, kept in the refrigerator and eaten within three to four days. That is not long, so freeze everything you will not eat that week on the day you make it.
The El Dorado County sheet allows its Pumpkin-Ginger Butter up to 3 weeks in the refrigerator after it has been frozen and thawed. That number belongs to that recipe. If you changed the recipe or made your own, use the Illinois rule.
How Do You Freeze Pumpkin Butter?
Cool it fast, pack it with room to expand, and label it. NCHFP’s freezing pumpkin directions cool cooked pumpkin by setting the pan in cold water and stirring now and then, then packing it with 1/2-inch headspace. The UC Master Food Preservers’ sheet uses the same 1/2-inch headspace for pumpkin butter.
| Storage | How long | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Refrigerator, fresh | 3 to 4 days | Illinois Extension |
| Refrigerator, after thawing (Pumpkin-Ginger Butter only) | Up to 3 weeks | UCCE Master Food Preservers, El Dorado County |
| Freezer, Pumpkin-Ginger Butter | Up to 8 months | UCCE Master Food Preservers, El Dorado County |
| Freezer, Classic Pumpkin Butter (from puree) | Up to 1 year | UCCE Master Food Preservers, El Dorado County |
| Canned, water bath or pressure | Not recommended | NCHFP; USDA Complete Guide (1994 revision) |
Thaw it in the refrigerator, not on the counter, and keep it there once it is thawed. Freeze it in half-pints so you thaw only what you will use.
Can You Give Pumpkin Butter as a Gift?
Yes, as long as the recipient knows it is a freezer food. The El Dorado County sheet says that if you gift a jar, be sure to tell your recipient how to store it. Hand it over frozen, with a tag on the lid that reads “Keep frozen. Thaw in the refrigerator. Use within 3 to 4 days of opening.” A shelf-stable-looking jar with a ribbon on it is exactly the jar somebody leaves in the pantry until spring.
And if part of the pumpkin pile is headed for dessert instead, Popular BBQ’s smoked pumpkin pie in cast iron is a good use for the rest.
A three-way tie: 30% each keep root crops in the fridge, in a cellar, basement or sand, or left in the garden.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you water-bath can pumpkin butter?
No. NCHFP and the USDA do not recommend canning pumpkin butter at all, in a water bath or a pressure canner. Refrigerate it or freeze it.
Does adding lemon juice or vinegar make pumpkin butter safe to can?
No. NCHFP says the pH of pumpkin varies too much for added acid to be counted on, and no tested process exists.
How long is homemade pumpkin butter good in the fridge?
Three to four days, according to Illinois Extension. Freeze anything you will not eat in that time.
How long can you freeze pumpkin butter?
The UC Master Food Preservers of El Dorado County list up to 8 months for their Pumpkin-Ginger Butter and up to 1 year for their classic pumpkin butter. Leave 1/2-inch headspace and thaw in the refrigerator.
Can I pressure can pumpkin instead?
Only as 1-inch cubes, using NCHFP’s tested process. Never as puree or butter. Mash the cubes after you open the jar.
Pumpkin butter is one of the best things you can do with a pie pumpkin, and it costs you nothing but freezer space to do it safely. Make a batch, freeze it in half-pints, and leave the canner for the cubes.
Sources: National Center for Home Food Preservation, “Beware: Pumpkin Butter” and “Freezing Pumpkin”; University of Georgia CAES, “Preserve Halloween pumpkin for holiday cooking” (Elizabeth Andress); Illinois Extension, Preserving Pumpkin; UC Cooperative Extension Master Food Preservers of El Dorado County, “Pumpkin Butter 3 Ways”; UC Master Food Preservers, “Freezer Pumpkin Butter and Other Goodies.”
Reader Favorites
- Dehydrators and Freeze Dryers: A Comparison for Food Preservation
- Seal the Deal: The Home Canning Chronicles – Preserving Flavor, One Jar at a Time
- Thriving in the Chill: A Guide to Winter Gardening
- Render Beef Tallow at Home: Master Homesteading Fat Now
- Hantavirus Prevention Tips for Homesteaders
- Top Homesteading Trends in 2026
Homestead reference charts
Three field guides worth bookmarking — canning times, cellar storage, and safe cooking temps.
| Food | Pressure | Pint |
|---|---|---|
| Green beans | 10 lb | 20m |
| Corn | 10 lb | 55m |
| Tomatoes | water bath | 35m |
USDA/NCHFP processing times & pressures for common foods.
View full chart →| Item | Store | Keeps |
|---|---|---|
| Onions | cool, dry | 9 mo |
| Potatoes | cellar | 4–6 mo |
| Apples | cellar | 6 mo |
How long fruit & veg keep in the cellar, fridge and freezer.
View full chart → Network| Doneness | Target |
|---|---|
| Rare | 125–130°F |
| Medium-rare | 130–135°F |
| Well-done | 160°F+ |
Safe pull temps for steak & burgers, from Popular BBQ.
View full chart →